I'm resurrecting this old blog post from January 10th of this year, so some of the references may be a little outdated. But I feel like this is a decent prequel to a blog I might write in the upcoming days that will probably alienate half of my readers, all 8 of you.
There  Are More Important Controversies Within The Red Wings…
Lately, with the (impressive, unexpected, heaven-sent,  over-achieving, amazing, whatever adjective you feel like throwing in  yourself) play of Jimmy Howard, there’s been a lot of talk about a  brewing number one goalie controversy in Detroit. Nobody within the  organization has come out and admitted Jimmy’s taking the number one  spot from Chris Osgood, and Jimmy still won’t talk about it like he  should (as in, “Oh, yeah, I’m the man, I rule, I’m so awesome, suck on  THAT, naysayers.”) But when he’s putting up stats where he’s only in the  bottom of the NHL pile in PIMs (0 for 31st place) and OTLs (2/30th),  and beating big-name goalies like Luongo, Kipprusoff and Nabokov and,  well, Osgood in stats like GAA and SV%, I think it’s safe to assume he’s  the man to beat on the Red Wings’ depth chart.
Let’s put it this way… he’s top 10 in those stats even when compared  to any NHL player who’s played a game as a goalie this season. That  means adding Ottawa’s Mike Brodeur’s 1 game, 1 goal against average to  the list and New Jersey’s Yann Denis’ 4 game .929 save percentage. Top  10. In the entire league. In the entire position.
So now that that’s been put to bed, I think it’s time we turn our  eyes to a more pressing controversy for the Red Wings and their fans.
Which team out there deserves the title of being our number one  rivalry?
Which team is the one that the players and the fans circle on their  calendars the day the NHL season schedule comes out and says “That’s our  big game!” Which team is the team that, no matter what the standings,  no matter the time of the year, you just want to see them get pummeled  on the ice and on the scoreboard. Which team is going to give the Red  Wings that little extra spark to their game because it’s a personal  game?
Many people make a case for the usual suspects: the Ducks, the  Blackhawks, the Blue Jackets, the Predators, and the Penguins of the  world. My school of thought is that if there are that many viable  options out there for a fan such as myself, then really, none of them  are options at all.
Think back from the mid-90s to the early 2000s. Who was it then?  Hands down, the Colorado Avalanche. Anyone who said otherwise was just  wrong. It was such a brutal rivalry that it still lingers to this day in  the hearts and the minds of the Wings faithful. Any time you see that  goofy maroon and teal color combination, admit it, you still get that  tightening in your stomach that makes you long for the better, bloodier  days. (Oh, and according to a little research, the official team colors  are “burgundy and steel blue, black, silver and white”. Whatever.)
I don’t know any team in the league right now that does that to me,  or to other fans. I can’t pinpoint a team that is just so hated, that  even if their nicest, most charitable, most talented player was up for  free agency or on the trading block, we’d still not like him in the  Winged Wheel. I can’t think of a team that when a Wings player leaves in  the off-season and signs with them, it’s considered a personal slight  and grounds for death or at the very least the sacrifice of their first  born to make amends.
The problem with today’s Wings -and today’s NHL, actually- is that  the league got exactly what it wanted when it went to the new(er)  schedule format. The 6 games against inter-division teams certainly did a  lot to manufacture rivalries, but the passion just isn’t there.
Yes, it’s easy to get physical when you’re playing a team that you  just played last week, and now’s your opportunity to get back at their  4th liner goon for that slash on your star player near the end of the  3rd period when the game was already settled. And yes, it’s easy to  build up the pressure and the atmosphere when you’re playing the team  that’s just 5 points ahead of you in the standings in a home-at-home  weekend series with little less than a month left in the season.
But it’s not easy to just force two teams together to the point where  just the mere sight of their jersey makes you see red, where you change  the channel when Sportscenter plays the highlights of that team’s  latest win (HA! Like that ever happens anymore, but bear with me…),  where you turn on your NHL video games and turn injuries all the way up  and difficulty all the way down so you can embarrass them just the way  you like it.
Calgary has Vancouver.
Boston has Montreal.
New York has… New York, I guess.
Detroit has, ummmm…
I don’t want to live in a world where I can’t go up to a fellow Red  Wings fan and mention [Team X], and know that I’ll soon get a front row  seat to their dark side’s emergence.